The Cookie Monster Ice Cream Shake Recipe That Could Scare Anyone

Our Cookie Monster Ice cream shake recipe is nothing short of MONSTROUS deliciousness!

Whether you’re looking for Cookie Monster Ice cream Milkshake near me, Cookie Monster shake from the Sugar Factory or even how to make a mean Monster cookie Protein Shake for your workouts, we’re your plug!

ALSO READ: Vanilla Yogurt Recipe: How To Make Vanilla Yogurt At Home

We’d like to say a big thank you to Emily Enchanted for providing us with these amazing Cookie Monster Shake pictures to use for this post.

About the Cookie Monster Ice cream shake recipe

Also called “Cookie Monster Freakshakes”, I guess you can say Freakshakes in general are the crazier Cousins of Milkshakes.

In summary, if I was to describe the Cookie Monster Milkshake, I’d say it’s a blue colored Shake with 2 different types of Cookies topped with whipped cream and some Chocolate drizzles.

If you had a fun Childhood, chances are you have a pretty good idea where the name “Cookie Monster” was derived from.

Remember that old kid’s show called Sesame Street that featured a bunch of Muppets? Yeah, that’s the one.

RECOMMENDED: Chapman Drink Recipe: How To Make Chapman Drink The Easiest Way

What brand makes Cookie Monster ice cream?

Tillamook, a prominent Creamery out at Oregon in the US is the brand famous for making Cookie Monster Ice Cream.

What flavor is blue monster ice cream?

It’s not surprising that one of the most asked questions when it comes to this Comfort food delicacy is what flavor is it? What does it actually taste like?

That blue coloring confuses the heck outta most people.

But that’s just all it is. Blue food coloring. The Cookie Monster Ice Cream is really just a Vanilla flavor.

So how do you make a monster milkshake?

Here are the most important ingredients that go into making a Cookie Monster shake recipe.

RELATED: Cremas Vs Coquito: The Difference Is Not What You Think

Ingredients you’ll need

• 5 pieces of Oreo cookies
• 5 pieces of Chocolate chip cookies
• 3 cups of Vanilla ice cream
• 1 cup of Milk
• Blue food coloring
• Whipped topping
• 2 tablespoons of Chocolate drizzle
• 2 pairs of Candy eyes (to make a true Freakshake Cookie monster)

Equipment you’ll need

1. A Zip lock bag
2. A Blender
3. 2 Drinking Glasses

How to make Cookie Monster Ice cream Shake

Image Source: Emily Enchanted

Step #1: To make your “crumble topping”, crush one Oreo cookie with one chocolate chip cookie in the Zip lock bag and set aside.

Step 2: Pour the 3 cups of Vanilla Ice Cream into a Blender and let it grind until smooth. You want to keep the power low.

Step 3: Pour in the blue food coloring and let the Blender run in low setting so the color gets around nicely.

Step 4: Stuff 3 Oreo cookies and 3 chocolate chip cookies into the Blender. You don’t want them to break into pieces so just like in step 3, keep the Blender running in low setting.

Step 5: Now pour the contents of the Blender into 2 tall glasses, crown it with 1/2 cup of the whipped toppings and a table spoon each of chocolate drizzle.

Step 6: Remember those cookies you crumbled earlier? Now take them and sprinkle atop the Monster Freakshake.

Lastly, grab those two pairs of candy Monster eyes and garnish the top of that little blue Muppet and VOILA! You have yourself a Cookie monster Ice cream shake!

ALSO READ: 29 Funny Names (And Shop Names) For Milkshakes You Won’t Believe

Cookie Monster Ice Cream shake near me: Where to buy

Image Source: Amanda’s Cookin

Trying to find where you can chug down a glass Cookie Monster Milkshake? Head over to Google Maps and you’ll see all the popular joints near your location, thanks to good Ol geolocation mumbo jumbo.

Now over to you

Did you try our Cookie Monster Ice Cream shake? Did you get it right and did you enjoy it? Was there any problem you faced while making it? Any contributions or opinions? Please share in the comments section below.

Follow Richeelicious on:

• Instagram
• Tik Tok
• YouTube
• Pinterest

STAY HUNGRY: Read more delicious Drink Recipes on Richeelicious.

Print Recipe

5 from 3 votes

Cookie Monster Ice Cream Milkshake

Our Cookie Monster Ice cream shake recipe is nothing short of MONSTROUS!

Whether you're looking for Cookie Monster Ice cream Milkshake near me, Cookie Monster shake from the Sugar Factory or even how to make a mean Monster cookie Protein Shake for your workouts, we're your plug!

Prep Time10 mins

Total Time10 mins

Course: Breakfast, Dessert, Drinks

Cuisine: American

Keyword: Cookie Monster ice cream milkshake recipe

Servings: 2 Glasses

Calories: 1226kcal

Author: The Last Food Bender

Equipment

• A Zip lock bag
• A Blender
• 2 Drinking Glasses

Ingredients

• 5 Pieces of Oreo cookies
• 5 Pieces of Chocolate chip cookies
• 3 Cups of Vanilla Ice Cream
• 1 Cup of Milk
• Blue food coloring
• Whipped toppings
• 2 Tablespoons of Chocolate drizzle
• 2 Pairs of Candy eyes (to make a true Freakshake Cookie monster)

Instructions

• To make your "crumble topping", crush one Oreo cookie with one chocolate chip cookie in the Ziplock bag and set aside
  
• Pour the 3 cups of Vanilla Ice Cream into a Blender and let it grind until smooth.
  
• Pour in the blue food coloring into the Blender
  
• Stuff 3 Oreo cookies and 3 chocolate chip cookies into the Blender
  
• Pour the contents of the Blender into 2 tall glasses, crown it with 1/2 cup of the whipped toppings and a table spoon each of chocolate drizzle.
  
• Take the crumbled cookies and sprinkle atop the Monster Freakshake.
  
• Add the two pairs of candy eyes to garnish the top of the Cookie Monster Ice cream
  

Video

Notes

• You want to keep the speed of the Blender low at all-times
• Even after you put in the whole cookies, you don't want them to break into pieces so just like above, keep the Blender running in low setting.